VW China recall of 384,000 cars could cost 3.7 billion yuan
Volkswagen AG recalled a record number of vehicles in China to replace defective gearboxes that may result in the loss of acceleration, in a move that may cost Europe's largest carmaker more than $600 million (3.7 billion yuan).
The recall of 384,181 vehicles, conducted by Volkswagen and its joint ventures, include the Golf, Magotan, Sagitar and Audi A3, China's quality inspector said on its website.
While Volkswagen declined to comment on the financial toll, research firm LMC Automotive estimated the replacement costs will range from 3,000 yuan ($483) to 10,000 yuan per vehicle.
The move is a blow for Volkswagen, which counts China as its biggest market. The recall comes less than a week after state broadcaster China Central Television featured Volkswagen customers in China complaining about abnormal vibrations, loss of power and sudden acceleration in cars equipped with the company's proprietary gearbox technology.
"It's always reputationally damaging to have to deal with an issue that plays out in the public's eyes," said Bill Russo, president of auto consultancy Synergistics Ltd. "Will they take a hit? Of course. The issue is how can they recover from that and how quickly can they recover."
21 models
The company said in an e-mailed statement that it is recalling vehicles with seven-speed direct-shift gearboxes, bearing the cost for replacing defective equipment and upgrading the software. LMC estimates Volkswagen sold about 680,000 vehicles equipped with the potentially faulty DSG gearboxes.
"There have been no injuries or accidents reported due to the DSG gearbox problem, as far as we know," Volkswagen China spokesman Christoph Ludewig said.
The recall covers 21 types of vehicles including versions of the Scirocco, Bora, Touran, Octavia and Passat models produced as far back as 2008 and as recently as this month, according to the state inspector's statement.
For Volkswagen, which sold 4 of China's top ten selling cars last year, complaints about its gearbox system in China aren't new. In May, the Wolfsburg, Germany-based carmaker agreed to extend the warranty for the transmission technology to 10 years, compared with the standard warranty of two years.
China's quality inspector said it began investigating complaints related to faulty Volkswagen gearboxes in March 2012.
Two months later, the company extended its warranty for the transmission system after several rounds of talks with the regulator, according to the statement.
A malfunction of electronics in the gearbox or inadequate pressure may result in the loss of power and present a safety threat, according to the regulator. Last May, Volkswagen spokesman Harthmuth Hoffmann said that the reported problems -- noise, vibrations and failure to start in hot and humid weather -- were "absolutely not a safety issue."
Volkswagen said Wednesday that although an electronic malfunction or a lack of oil pressure may result in a power interruption, steering and braking functions wouldn't be affected. That means that even if the car loses power on the road, the driver would be able to safely stop the car, it said.
China's quality regulator said it interviewed more than 3,000 consumers, received more than 10,000 defect reports, conducted 12 spot checks and held 7 hearings with automotive experts before concluding that the Volkswagen gearboxes were defective and posed a safety concern.
New laws
The move also comes after China introduced recall laws this year giving the watchdog broader powers to order investigations and impose fines on companies that fail to call back faulty products in a timely manner.
Volkswagen and its ventures sold 2.8 million vehicles in China last year, second only to General Motors among foreign automakers. The German company and its Chinese partners generated operating profit of 3.7 billion euros (29.7 billion yuan) last year, up by 1.1 billion euros from the previous year.
Other German automakers have also faced scrutiny in the past week from CCTV, which said it found asphalt in Chinese-made models of cars made by Audi, BMW and Mercedes-Benz.
Samples taken from vehicles showed traces of asphalt, a road-paving material also used for reducing vibrations, CCTV reported. Owners reported a pungent smell in their cars and physical symptoms such as dizziness and swollen fingers, according to the CCTV report.
Representatives from all three companies said they have started investigations. Audi China spokesman Martin Kuehl said Audi has the same "strict standards" for all of its parts globally, while Daimler spokesman Senol Bayrak said all its vehicles manufactured in China use only imported vibration-damping materials that comply with existing regulations.
The three German luxury brands command about 74 percent of China's luxury segment, according to estimates from researcher IHS Global Insight.
While the report might not significantly affect total luxury car sales, it could push Chinese consumers toward choosing imported models of luxury marques over models manufactured in China, according to John Zeng, Shanghai-based managing director at LMC Automotive.
Tata Motors Ltd.'s Jaguar Land Rover and Zhejiang Geely Holding Group Co.'s Volvo Cars may benefit since they focus on imports, he said.
"People will choose the import models, because they realize that on quality levels, the import models are very different from locally-made ones," Zeng said.
While Volkswagen declined to comment on the financial toll, research firm LMC Automotive estimated the replacement costs will range from 3,000 yuan ($483) to 10,000 yuan per vehicle.
The move is a blow for Volkswagen, which counts China as its biggest market. The recall comes less than a week after state broadcaster China Central Television featured Volkswagen customers in China complaining about abnormal vibrations, loss of power and sudden acceleration in cars equipped with the company's proprietary gearbox technology.
"It's always reputationally damaging to have to deal with an issue that plays out in the public's eyes," said Bill Russo, president of auto consultancy Synergistics Ltd. "Will they take a hit? Of course. The issue is how can they recover from that and how quickly can they recover."
21 models
The company said in an e-mailed statement that it is recalling vehicles with seven-speed direct-shift gearboxes, bearing the cost for replacing defective equipment and upgrading the software. LMC estimates Volkswagen sold about 680,000 vehicles equipped with the potentially faulty DSG gearboxes.
"There have been no injuries or accidents reported due to the DSG gearbox problem, as far as we know," Volkswagen China spokesman Christoph Ludewig said.
The recall covers 21 types of vehicles including versions of the Scirocco, Bora, Touran, Octavia and Passat models produced as far back as 2008 and as recently as this month, according to the state inspector's statement.
For Volkswagen, which sold 4 of China's top ten selling cars last year, complaints about its gearbox system in China aren't new. In May, the Wolfsburg, Germany-based carmaker agreed to extend the warranty for the transmission technology to 10 years, compared with the standard warranty of two years.
China's quality inspector said it began investigating complaints related to faulty Volkswagen gearboxes in March 2012.
Two months later, the company extended its warranty for the transmission system after several rounds of talks with the regulator, according to the statement.
A malfunction of electronics in the gearbox or inadequate pressure may result in the loss of power and present a safety threat, according to the regulator. Last May, Volkswagen spokesman Harthmuth Hoffmann said that the reported problems -- noise, vibrations and failure to start in hot and humid weather -- were "absolutely not a safety issue."
Volkswagen said Wednesday that although an electronic malfunction or a lack of oil pressure may result in a power interruption, steering and braking functions wouldn't be affected. That means that even if the car loses power on the road, the driver would be able to safely stop the car, it said.
China's quality regulator said it interviewed more than 3,000 consumers, received more than 10,000 defect reports, conducted 12 spot checks and held 7 hearings with automotive experts before concluding that the Volkswagen gearboxes were defective and posed a safety concern.
New laws
The move also comes after China introduced recall laws this year giving the watchdog broader powers to order investigations and impose fines on companies that fail to call back faulty products in a timely manner.
Volkswagen and its ventures sold 2.8 million vehicles in China last year, second only to General Motors among foreign automakers. The German company and its Chinese partners generated operating profit of 3.7 billion euros (29.7 billion yuan) last year, up by 1.1 billion euros from the previous year.
Other German automakers have also faced scrutiny in the past week from CCTV, which said it found asphalt in Chinese-made models of cars made by Audi, BMW and Mercedes-Benz.
Samples taken from vehicles showed traces of asphalt, a road-paving material also used for reducing vibrations, CCTV reported. Owners reported a pungent smell in their cars and physical symptoms such as dizziness and swollen fingers, according to the CCTV report.
Representatives from all three companies said they have started investigations. Audi China spokesman Martin Kuehl said Audi has the same "strict standards" for all of its parts globally, while Daimler spokesman Senol Bayrak said all its vehicles manufactured in China use only imported vibration-damping materials that comply with existing regulations.
The three German luxury brands command about 74 percent of China's luxury segment, according to estimates from researcher IHS Global Insight.
While the report might not significantly affect total luxury car sales, it could push Chinese consumers toward choosing imported models of luxury marques over models manufactured in China, according to John Zeng, Shanghai-based managing director at LMC Automotive.
Tata Motors Ltd.'s Jaguar Land Rover and Zhejiang Geely Holding Group Co.'s Volvo Cars may benefit since they focus on imports, he said.
"People will choose the import models, because they realize that on quality levels, the import models are very different from locally-made ones," Zeng said.
